Skip to content
Electric Vs Pellet Smoker

Electric vs Pellet Smoker - What Are The Differences?

Electric Vs Pellet Smoker

You're finally ready to take the plunge and get a dedicated smoker.
Congratulations for making such an outstanding pick!

The questioning will now begin. What kind of smoker should you buy? There are five types: wood/charcoal, pellet, gas, and electric.

Which makes the tastiest food? Which option is the least expensive? What is the least amount of annoyance possible? Which option offers the most value for money?

Our article includes the answers to these and other questions to aid you in deciding which kind of smoker to buy.

To begin, what are your smoking goals for this individual? Are you on a shoestring budget? What amount of time and effort are you prepared to devote to your smoking habit?

Before you invest in a smoker, consider the following factors when determining the kind of smoker that is right for you.

Bear in mind that each kind has a range of price ranges and degrees of durability. Your purpose may be to purchase the best smoker for less than $200 or $300. Pricing, on the other hand, may not be a concern for you.

If you make the wrong choice today, you almost likely will be back shopping in a year or two!

Are you seeking to compare an electric smoker to a pellet smoker? Not sure which is healthier for you or which kind of smoker to purchase?

Continue reading and we'll lead you through a checklist of the advantages and disadvantages of each to assist you in determining which is the ideal electric or pellet smoker for you.

Once you've narrowed your search to a particular kind of smoker, you can begin thoroughly studying your possibilities. As a result, let us explore the different types of smokers and assess their relative merits and demerits.

How Important Is The Flavor?

It's mostly a question of personal preference. Both of these approaches involve heating an element with electricity. The heat sources, on the other hand, are unique, and they make a world of difference in terms of flavor.

The contrast is that an electric smoker relies entirely on the element to generate heat, while a pellet smoker relies on a huge number of wood pellets to generate heat. Around 2 pounds each hour.

Each electric smoker has a box – some are insulated, some are not – a heat source, and a tray for wood chips or chunks. The electric element heats the box and smolders the wood, resulting in the production of smoke. The process is non-combustible.

The element generates all of the heat, and all that results is hot air and a trace of water vapor. It's a steaming, smokey oven. While electric smokers produce some delectable dinners, let's wait and see what pellets produce before determining which is the best choice for us.

A pellet smoker's electric element is used to ignite wood pellets, which create heat and smoke. Combustion takes place. The heat source is wood, not an electrical device. We get a variety of gases and certain solids.

That is the fundamental distinction between the two (apart from pricing). Electric smokers provide heat, steam (through a water pan), and a little bit of smoke, all of which help to the meat's flavor.

By contrast, a pellet smoker creates heat and a huge volume of smoke, gases, and solids via burning. These extra gases and solids contribute to the delicious flavor. The principal pollutants are Nitrogen Oxide (NO) and Carbon Monoxide (CO) (CO).

The flavor variation between the two kinds is a key differentiator.

No matter how much money you spend on an electric smoker, it will never produce the correct mixture of gases to impart the smokey flavor, smoke ring, and bark associated with high-quality BBQ.

To be completely candid, electric smokers provide fantastic tender, juicy, and tasty dinners. Pellet smokers, on the other hand, provide flavors that electric smokers are unable to achieve owing to their construction.

How Important Is Accessibility?

Both electric and pellet smokers are very simple to use and need minimal maintenance. They are, in essence, set and forget. Typically, the Lazy-Q brand is associated with electric smokers. These smokers are often referred to be slothful.

There is no fuss or commotion. Preheat the oven, add the meat, and wait for the temperature to reach the desired level. It doesn't get much more straightforward than this.

Wipe away the ashes after each use of the pellet smoker, but the electric smoker needs you to remove the burnt wood pieces and the tin foil you coated the bottom with before to each cook. Each task will almost certainly need the same amount of time and effort.

Both types of smokers excel at low and slow cooking - which is basically the objective of a smoker. If you are unable to cook anything low and slow – such as brisket or pig butt – you will be unable to sufficiently break down the muscle structure for the tender and succulent BBQ you want.

As a result, let's analyze this. Both are quite easy to operate and need little maintenance.

You may need to replace some aluminum foil in an electric smoker; with a pellet smoker, you may need to empty the ash bin and refill the hopper with fresh pellets. Between the two, there is a disparity in terms of result and expense.

The electric smoker, and to a great degree all electric smokers, make food that is very delicious but lacks flavor from the smoke. As a result, exquisite fall-off-the-bone ribs, delectable pulled pork, and delightful tri-tip are on the menu.

However, this is not the case when it comes to smoke rings and bark. On the other side, pellet grills provide excellent flavor and ease of usage.

Let us not make the mistake of assuming you're just interested in smoking meat. Many people like smoking cheese, salmon, and nuts, among other things. You may use an electric smoker to set and sustain very low temperatures.

Both kinds need electricity to function, and so have nothing in common in terms of versatility. Electric smokers, on the other hand, are often more compact and lightweight than pellet smokers. What does this really mean? Portability.

The notion of hauling a pellet smoker in a truck is unattractive. However, the typical electric smoker is rather small and light. Around the size of a dorm room refrigerator, but far lighter.

As a result, if mobility (with access to energy) is a concern, electric vehicles provide an advantage.

Another component of adaptation is the location of one's residence and the permissible activities. An electric smoker is normally authorized if you live in an apartment or condominium and have access to a balcony or other small area.

Generally, these situations will exclude the use of a pellet grill or smoker.

How Important Is Operation Cost?

There is a significant difference between the two. An electric smoker creates smoke via the use of electricity and maybe 3-6 ounces of wood.

You may acquire wood for a number of electric smokers from a range of dealers located around the United States. Additionally, you are not needed to utilize a certain brand or format depending on the kind and model of electric smoker you possess.

Each hour, a pellet smoker eats around 1-2 pounds of pellets, while an electric smoker consumes approximately 6-8 ounces of pellets. Pellets cost around $1 per pound, which equates to a ten-hour roast costing $10.

Is the difference in flavor worth it? While this is true for the vast majority of individuals, there are other considerations to make before firing the trigger.

How Important Is The Cost Of Purchase?

Significant difference here. While an electric smoker is often less costly than a very outstanding gas grill, pellet smokers are typically more expensive. This is an important factor to consider and one of the most difficult aspects of the decision-making process.

A pellet smoker will not suffice if you do not own a grill. You're unlikely to want to start the pellet smoker only to cook a couple of burgers. Having said that, you will not be driving an electric car for that purpose.

The decision here is whether you want to dip your toe in the water and start smoking meats without making a large financial commitment - or if you're ready to spend about $1,000 on the entry level pellet smokers available.

Prices only go up from there if you're looking for a high end unit or one that you can build in to your outdoor kitchen.

Cheap electric smokers start at around $200. They can go way up in cost depending on capability, quality of build, and a variety of other factors.

The higher price points represent a trade-off between more capacity, improved fit and finish, and a degree of quality that should last for years. It is still an electric smoker, subject to the limitations imposed by the heat source.

Final Thoughts

Finally, the option is entirely up to you. Between these two types of smokers, a significant trade-off between flavor (at a price) and ultimate convenience and economy must be decided.

If you live in a region where open flames are prohibited, you are compelled to use an electric.

If you have the resources and desire, though, a pellet smoker is an outstanding cooker. If you already possess a decent gas grill, you may completely eliminate the sear box.

For a multitude of reasons, pellet smokers have risen in popularity.

They are high-tech, automated, precise, and regularly provide exceptional results. When it comes to smoking meat and producing amazing BBQ, nothing beats burning wood.

Pellet grills are constructed entirely of wood. If you're unfamiliar with how they work, it's a simple concept. They, like an electric smoker, keep an eye on and regulate the temperature.

The difference is that temperature is adjusted by regulating the amount of wood pellets burned in the fire box at any given time.

These are wonderful demonstrations of technology, apparatus, and, in some cases, art. If you have the budget and want the best results without managing a fire, a pellet grill is the way to go.

Electric smokers are the simplest way to consistently produce soft, juicy barbecue ribs, pulled pork, and smoked beef brisket.

Others may provide a stronger flavor of smoke, but our electric smokers produce some great 'Que. And for smoked salmon, smoked cheese, and smoked nuts, the only practical alternative is an electric smoker.

Next article Outdoor Grill Ventilation: When Do You Need An Outdoor Vent Hood And Why Is It Important?